Stereotypes of animals
When anthropomorphising a (non-human) animal there are stereotypical traits which commonly tend to be associated with particular species. Often these are simply exaggerations of real aspects or behaviours of the creature in question, while other times the stereotype is taken from mythology and the true origins are forgotten. Some are popularised or solidified by a single particularly notable appearance in media, for example Disney's 1942 film Bambi which portrayed the titular deer as an innocent, fragile animal.[1] In any case, once they have entered the culture as widely-recognized stereotypes of animals, they tend to be used both in conversation and media as a kind of shorthand for expressing particular qualities.
While some authors make use of these animal stereotypes "as is", others undermine reader expectations by reversing them, developing the animal character in the exact opposite direction (e.g. a fastidious pig or a cowardly lion).
Many modern stereotypes of animals have a long tradition dating back to Aesop's Fables, which drew upon sources that included Ancient Egyptian animal tales. Aesop's stereotypes were so deeply ingrained by the time of Apollonius of Tyana that they were accepted as representative of various animals' "true" natures:
And there is another charm about him, namely, that he puts animals in a pleasing light and makes them interesting to mankind. For after being brought up from childhood with these stories, and after being as it were nursed by them from babyhood, we acquire certain opinions of the several animals and think of some of them as royal animals, of others as silly, of others as witty, and others as innocent.
Discussion
It is important to note that many animal stereotypes reflect anthropomorphic notions which are unfair to impose upon actual animals in nature. Thus, while a shark is instinctively feeding in the way its nature intends, in folklore it tends to be classified as "cruel", a word which implies a conscious and immoral choice to cause unnecessary pain. Yet conscience and morality are metaphysical attributes which are imposed by humans and do not exist as such within the shark's world. Likewise, some stereotypes are based on mistaken or grossly oversimplified impressions, e.g. spotted hyenas are stereotypically portrayed as cowardly scavengers, but in reality they are efficient pack hunters with a complex social structure who care for their young.
Despite these considerations, the use of such animal stereotypes is generally much less problematic than it is for human stereotypes (to which some of the same issues apply), for obvious reasons.
Common Western animal stereotypes
Mammals
Bats
- The bloodthirsty or evil bat
- Among 1.000 species of bats, only 3 feed on blood. This stereotypical image is based on vampire stories.
- Bats are often said to be blind, such as in the expression "as blind as a bat", when in reality bats are not blind, but Microbats have poor visual acuity. In contrast, some Megabats have very good vision.
- Another stereotype associated with bats is that the animal will fly into your hair. This is an urban legend since bats can navigate very well in the dark thanks to their echolocation system.
Bears
Bulls
- The aggressive bull who attacks everyone and everything with the color red
- This stereotype can be found in many comic strips and cartoons and is based on bullfighting where the bullfighter taunts the bull by waving a small red cape (muleta). This has led to the urban legend that bulls will attack anything in the color red. In reality bulls are dichromatic and attack the waving cape instead of the color. The reason those capes have the color red is its association with blood and the tradition itself.
Cats
- The cool cat
- The lazy cat
- The evil/villainous cat
- Many cartoons portray cats as mischievous, crafty, unreliable and antagonistic. Examples: Pegleg Pete, Tom from Tom and Jerry, the cats in An American Tail, Sylvester, Mr. Jinks, Lucifer, Catnip, The Cat from "Pinocchio"
- In ancient superstition a black cat is often believed to bring bad luck.
- Witches are often accompanied by black cats.
- A cruel game where the hunter teases his victim before finally striking him is called a cat-and-mouse game in many languages. The concept is based on the behaviour that real cats often showcase before killing their prey.
- Other pejorative expressions associated with cats can be found in the Dutch language. "Kattengejank" literally means "screaming cats" and is used to describe the sounds people make who cannot sing. "Kattenkwaad" (literally: "Evil cat behaviour") is used to describe bad children's behaviour.
- The cute kitten
Dogs
- The loyal or heroic dog
- Dogs are often called "man's best friend". Many stories feature them as heroes who save the day or help their master in dangerous situations. Detectives and police man often use them to search criminals. They are also often used as watch dogs.
- Many stories, especially cartoons, portray them as the natural enemy of cats.
- Examples: Pluto, Old Yeller, Benji, Rin Tin Tin, Lassie, 101 Dalmatians, Lady and the Tramp, Ace the Wonder Dog, Snowy, Dogmatix, Joost the loyal butler (Tom Poes)
- The dim-witted dog
- The vicious bull dog
- The depressed or low-key behaving bassett hound
- Poodles are portrayed as being either posh and/or snobbish. They sometimes speak with a French accent
- Saint Bernards are often portrayed carrying a small barrel of brandy around their neck to warm victims lost in the snowy mountains. This is however an urban legend, caused by a painting by Edwin Landseer called "Alpine Mastiffs Reanimating a Distressed Traveler." (http://www.cracked.com/article/105_the-6-most-frequently-quoted-bullshit-animal-facts/)
- Apart from bull dogs, pit bulls or dobermanns people don't often portray dogs as villainous or dangerous characters.
Donkeys
- The stubborn or stupid ass
- Examples: Nick Bottom, Donkey, stupid and naughty children are transformed in donkeys in Pinocchio,...
- In previous centuries schools often forced naughty or "dumb" pupils to sit in a class room corner with a donkey eared hat on their head.
- The horny or virile donkey/stallion/bull
Elephants
- The unforgetting elephant
- The mice-fearing elephant
- The strict and imposing elephant who doesn't tolerate nonsense.
- Drunks are often depicted as if they see pink elephants or pink rabbits while being intoxicated.
Foxes
- The wily, cruel, cunning or intelligent fox
Goats
- Goats are often portrayed as omnivores, who eat everything, especially things made from iron.
- Goats are usually anthropomorphized as old men with a goatee.
Hippopotamuses
Horses
- The noble horse
- Horses are traditionally seen as noble creatures since humans use them for transport. In quite a few countries, like Great Britain, eating horse meat is therefore seen as a taboo. Many languages describe the horse's paws as "legs", an honor that few other animals receive.
- Examples of noble horses: Black Beauty, Rocinante, Trigger, Silver, Jolly Jumper, Pegasus, Sleipnir,...
- The virile horse.
Hyenas
- The comical / always-laughing hyena
- The cruel, bullying hyena
Kangaroos
- The boxing kangaroo
- Another myth associated with the kangaroo is that people can climb inside its pouch and be carried around. This general misconception was famously debunked in The Simpsons episode Bart vs. Australia.
Lemmings
- The suicidal lemming
- Lemmings tend to migrate in large numbers, which can include jumping off cliffs into the water and swimming great distances to the point of exhaustion and even death. However in these cases it's pure accidental and not intentionally trying to kill itself. Lemmings don't even deliberately throw themselves off cliffs. This stereotype was influenced by a Disney documentary, White Wilderness (1958) where the animals were chased off a cliff by the documentary makers, purely for some sensational images.
Lions
- The proud, brave, noble or royal lion
Mice
- The quiet mouse
- Mice are frequently portrayed in animation as shy and physically frail, often bookish, nerdy and/or glasses-wearing.
- The heroic mouse
Moles
- The blind or near sighted mole
Moose
Pigs
- The greedy, ugly and/or filthy pig
- Both aspects are due to the natural pig lifestyle (when raised on a farm rather than a feedlot)—"greedy" from the way they devour any food put in front of them, "filthy" from the fact that a pig-sty is generally a soup of mud and feces which the pigs don't seem to mind at all (this also gives rise to the saying "Happy as a pig in shit").
- The stereotype may also derive in part from Judeo-Islamic cultures, whose concepts of kosher/halal teach that pigs are "unclean" for various reasons.
- Examples of greedy and filthy pigs: Napoleon and other pigs in Animal Farm
- "Pig" is a pejorative nickname for a filthy or ugly person in many languages.
- Example of an ugly pig: Miss Piggy.
- Pigs are also portrayed as straight men or sidekicks (for example Porky Pig, Orson (U.S. Acres), Cornfed,...
Rabbits/Hares
- The horny rabbit or hare - Following naturally from the phrase "(to) breed like rabbits". Another stereotype derived from the wild behaviour of rabbits during mating season is the expression "as mad as a March Hare."
- The hyperactive / fast-running rabbit / hare (Again, generally not distinguished from each other.)
- The smart rabbit or hare
Raccoons
Rats
- The evil or kleptomaniacal rat
- In contrast with mice, rats are almost always depicted as villains or dangerous creatures. This image is also derived from the rats' reputation as a carrier of The Black Death and other diseases : The rat in Lady and the Tramp, Professor Rattigan in The Great Mouse Detective, the rats in Redwall and in the films Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, Willard, Rats, Nosferatu, eine Symphonie des Grauens, ...
- Ben, the title character in the film Ben, Remy in Ratatouille and The Rats of Nimh in The Secret of NIMH are an exception, being depicted as generally quite civilised.
Seals
Simians
- The funny monkey/ape
- The mischievous monkey
- The monstrous or brutish ape (usually a gorilla)
- The amorous ape who lusts for human women
Skunks
- The smelly skunk
- Chuck Jones' Pepé Le Pew is one of the best-known animated skunks and propagates the idea that the animals emit their scent continuously. Human characters often run in panic from the mere sight or smell of a skunk.
Sloths
- The lazy sloth
- Sloth, one of the seven deadly sins, meaning spiritual apathy.
- Sid the prehistoric sloth in the Ice Age films is depicted as lively and fast-talking, in contrast to the stereotype.
Squirrels
Tigers
Walruses
Weasels
- The sneaky and thieving weasel who always manages to flee.
Wolves
- The cruel or evil wolf
- The honorable wolf
- Through the latter half of the 20th century, the wolf was increasingly portrayed in the opposite manner of the evil wolf, as an especially dignified and capable wild form of dog and symbol of nature. (e.g. the Kevin Costner film, Dances with Wolves)
- The solitary or renegade wolf
Birds
Chickens
Crows/Ravens
- The ominous raven or crow
- Ravens or crows often foretell death and destruction, as portrayed in Edgar Allan Poe's poem "The Raven." Also, in Celtic and Irish myths, goddesses of war often appeared in the form of a raven or crow. The stereotype of ravens portraying death could stem from the fact that they are often seen feasting on the gore of dead soldiers after battle.
- The Afro-American crow
- In the 19th and early 20th century white Americans often compared black people with crows, due to the black colour of the bird. Crows in these stereotypical depictions speak in jive.
- Examples: Jim Crow, the crows in Dumbo, the comic strip and animated version of Fritz the Cat
Ducks
- The overconfident, arrogant duck who isn't as smart as he thinks.
Eagles
- The child-stealing eagle
- The proud, noble eagle
Geese
Magpies
Ostriches
- The nervous ostrich
- Ostriches are often portrayed as being nervous and are widely thought to bury their heads in the sand at the first sign of danger. In reality this is not true; the ostrich is more likely to respond by fleeing, or, failing in that, delivering powerful kicks, easily capable of killing a man or a lion.[3]
Owls
- The wise owl
- In Greek mythology, Athena is the goddess of wisdom and is regularly associated with the owl.[4]
- Other examples: The wise owls in Winnie the Pooh, The Animals of Farthing Wood, Guardians of Ga'Hoole, Bambi and The Sword in the Stone
- Although owls are often associated with wisdom and intelligence this image is not timeless, nor universal. During the Middle Ages, owls were seen as dumb, stupid and evil helpers of witches. On many paintings of Hieronymus Bosch the bird can be seen as a symbol of stupidity and/or evil. The Dutch profanity word "uilskuiken" ("owl chick") is used to insult a stupid person and the Dutch saying "Wat baten kaars en bril als de uil niet zien wil?" ("What use are a candle and glasses if the owl refuses to see?") still reminds people of this totally opposite view of owls. In Asian culture owls are traditionally seen as dumb animals instead of symbols of wisdom.
Parrots
- The talkative, annoying, and/or smartypants parrot/cockatoo (no distinction)
- Example Paulie, Flip in Jommeke, Iago in the Disney film Aladdin
- Parrots are also often portrayed as if they can actually conversate with people, whereas real parrots can only mimick certain sounds.
Peacocks
- The proud peacock
- From the saying: "as proud as a peacock".
- Peacocks are often used as a symbol of vanity and pride.
Penguins
Pheasants
Storks
- The baby-delivering stork
- In western folklore, parents have told their children for centuries that babies are delivered by a stork. Examples can be found in the film Dumbo and the short Lambert the Sheepish Lion.
Reptiles and amphibians
Crocodiles
- The weeping and hypocritical crocodile
- Many political cartoons, legends and stories feature crocodiles who claim to be sad about someone else's grief and then cry fake tears as a result. This stereotype is based on the fact that in real life crocodiles can often be observed with teary eyes while they consume their dead prey. The reason for this behaviour lies is that crocodiles are unable to chew and thus forced to rip their food into chunks and swallow them whole. Since the glands that keep their eyes moist are right near their throats this eating habit actually forces them to produce tears. This observation lead humans to believe that crocodiles are crying about the death of the animal they hypocritically just killed themselves and created the expression "crying crocodile tears", which means that one shows emotions without really meaning it.
- The villainous crocodile/alligator
Dinosaurs
Frogs/Toads
- Toads and frogs are often anthropomorphized into fat people.
Snakes
- The evil or untrustworthy snake
Turtles/Tortoises
Fish and sea mammals
Dolphins
Sharks
Whales
Invertebrates
Ants
- The diligent ant
- This stems mainly from a fable, The Ant and the Grasshopper, in which the ant works hard to prepare for the winter while the grasshopper wastes the summer and fall having fun, only to have to beg food from the ant or starve.
- The militant ant
- Ants, like many animals that form colonies or hives, are known for working together like an army. Some popular culture have the ants portray as military soldiers.
- The thieving/bothersome ant.
- Ants are often portrayed stealing food from picnics, kitchens, etc. Examples can be found in many cartoons, like Tom and Jerry.
Bees
Crickets and grasshoppers
- Crickets and grasshoppers look very similar and because of this they are often confused with each other.
- The violin playing cricket/grasshopper
- Male crickets are known for the chirping sound they make. In some cultures this sound is seen as a sign of good luck, while in other cultures it is associated with bad luck. Some cartoons depict crickets as violinists because the movements they make to produce their chirping sound resemble someone playing a violin.
- Examples: The grasshopper in the Disney cartoon The Grasshopper and the Ants and in Roald Dahl's James and the Giant Peach.
- The lazy / carefree grasshopper
- This stems mainly from a fable, The Ant and the Grasshopper, in which the ant works hard to prepare for the winter while the grasshopper wastes the summer and fall having fun, only to have to beg for food from the ant or starve. For this reason, grasshoppers are also sometimes characterized as social parasites (as in the Pixar movie A Bug's Life).
- An exception is the Old-Green-Grasshopper in Roald Dahl's James and the Giant Peach, who is portrayed as a well-mannered gentleman and musician.
Mantises
- The patient mantis
- Because mantises are able to wait for hours for food to approach them.
- The sinister/evil mantis
Spiders
Squid
- The man eating monstrous giant squid who attacks and destroys ships
- Octopuses are also often portrayed as dangerous sea creatures.
- Many propaganda posters often portray persons or ideologies as an octopus sitting on a globe spreading its tentacles to take over the entire world
- Ursula the Sea Witch in Disney's The Little Mermaid has octopus-like tentacles
- Examples: Mega Shark Versus Giant Octopus
Termites
- The destructive termite
- Because of the termite's reputation of eating wood and wrecking homes and buildings, which is greatly exaggerated in cartoons
Wasps
- The wanton and vicious wasp
- Wasps are often portrayed as deliberate stingers of humans.
Common East Asian animal stereotypes
Animal stereotypes in East Asian cultures (China, Japan, Korea, etc.) include:
- The loyal / savage dog
- While domesticated dogs were welcomed, wild dogs were dangerous to both humans and their cattle.
- The royal elephant
- Most notable in Thailand and India, elephants are symbols of royalty.
- The proud horse
- The thieving mouse
- As a mouse was a common pest, they were likened to thieves. However, in Japanese tradition, a mouse also guarantees a good harvest.
- The comical or lecherous octopus
- The stupid / rich pig
- The lucky / acquisitive cat
- Cats are said to bring luck to business ventures. Many Japanese video games feature anthropomorphic cats ("neko") in mercantile roles (e.g. Square's Secret of Mana) as well.
- The cute kitten
- Catgirls occupy a niche in Japanese otaku culture, most often as females dressed to some degree as a humanoid with cat elements like cat ears and a tail.
- The devoted / tricky rabbit
- The former is from a Buddhist story where a rabbit offered itself as a gift to Buddha by leaping into a fire. In Kojiki, a white rabbit appears as a trickster. This is also due to the mythology of the rabbit in the moon.
- In a Korean folktale, a wise rabbit rescues a man from a greedy, ungrateful tiger.
- The friendly snake
- The proud tiger
- The cruel tiger
- The folktales about man-devouring tigers appear frequently in Korea. At times tigers can be gullible or loyal.
- The wise and old turtle / tortoise
- The protecting wolf
- The wolf protected Japanese farmers crops from raiders.
- The grateful/loyal magpie
- In Korea, a magpie chirping near one's house indicates that long-anticipated guests are finally coming.
- In one Korean folktale, a magpie sacrifices herself to save the man who rescued her chicks from a serpent.
- In Japanese folklore, the kitsune and fox represent the trickster, similar to the jackal in Africa, or coyote and fox in North America.
Indian animal stereotypes
India has a rich tradition of animal stories and beast fables, including one of the world's oldest collections of stories, the Panchatantra, and its later derivatives such as the Hitopadesha. Throughout these fables, the talking animals behave as humans (unlike the Aesop model where animals behave as animals), and, are used to invoke characters with stereotypical personalities. There is also a distinction between wild and domesticated animals. Some of the common stereotypes include:
- Lion: Is king of the forest, and demonstrates all the royal strengths and weaknesses. Is brave, noble and proud animal, but can also be haughty and foolish. Has a natural rivalry with the elephant.[5]
- Jackal: Is greedy and cunning (akin to the fox in European tradition), and sometimes gets punished but often gets away. Is often a manipulative minister to the king.[6]
- Hare: Is small and vulnerable, but compensates for it by being crafty, outwitting stronger rivals.[6]
- Elephant (wild or domestic): Is noble, proud and strong, and an enemy of the lion, but like the lion can also be naive, and, when in rut, wild and unpredictable.[7]
- Cat (domestic or wild): Is cunning and hypocritical, with a calm appearance hiding murderous intentions.[8]
- Dog: Is considered unclean and impure, and is reviled—not a pet but a pest. Is considered to lack self-respect.[7]
- Mongoose (domestic): Is a loyal and useful pet, best known for its natural enmity toward snakes. See The Brahmin and the Mongoose.[9]
References
- ^ Eaton, Marcia. "Fact and Fiction in Aes App of Nature". Accessed 17 September 2006.
- ^ Philostratus, Flavius (c.210 CE). The Life of Apollonius of Tyan, 5.14. Translated by F.C. Conybeare. the Loeb Classical Library (1912)
- ^ Straight Dope. 26 May 1999. "Do ostriches really bury their heads in the sand?". Accessed 15 September 2006.
- ^ Stebbins, Elinor. 1998. "Pallas Athena, Goddess of Wisdom". Accessed 17 September 2006.
- ^ Olivelle p. 29, Törzsök p. 41.
- ^ a b Törzsök p. 40, Olivelle p. 29
- ^ a b Törzsök p. 39, Olivelle p. 28
- ^ Törzsök p. 37, Olivelle p. 27
- ^ Törzsök p. 42, Olivelle p. 30